Most of the losses that have made the news in this industry were not investment losses. They were custody failures — assets that were not where clients believed them to be, held by an entity that was also the investment manager, with nobody independent checking.
These are the six questions we would ask any manager, including us. Ask for the answers in writing.
1. Who holds the assets, and are they a different legal entity from you?
If the manager is also the custodian, there is no independent party to notice a discrepancy. That is the single most important structural question, and it should be answered in one sentence.
2. Are client assets segregated from company assets?
Commingled assets are indistinguishable from company assets in an insolvency. Segregation should be a matter of record, reported per client, not a matter of intent.
3. How many independent signatures does a withdrawal require?
One signature is one compromised laptop. Multi-signature authorisation across independent key holders should be the default, with a mandatory delay on any address that has not been used before.
4. How often are balances reconciled, and by whom?
Daily, by someone who does not report to the investment desk. Monthly reconciliation performed by the desk itself is not a control.
5. What happens if you cease trading tomorrow?
There should be a documented, tested procedure by which clients recover their assets without the manager's cooperation. If nobody can describe it, it does not exist.
6. Will you put all of the above in writing?
This is the question that matters. Every firm answers the first five well in conversation. Considerably fewer will sign the answers.
